How Custom Pins Can Drive Community Engagement

Custom pins might seem like old-school gamification—after all, the military and monarchies have been awarding pins for centuries—but their ability to drive behavior change remains highly relevant today. For sustainability managers, pins offer a tangible way to reward achievements, foster identity, and inspire commitment to environmental goals.

Why Pins Work for Sustainability Initiatives

The human mind is wired to respond to recognition, particularly when it’s from an authority figure. Pins tap into this psychological mechanism by serving as symbols of achievement, belonging, and mastery. A well-designed pin awarded for completing a sustainability milestone—such as reducing household waste or planting trees—can amplify motivation and encourage continued participation.

The secret to pins lies in their scarcity. When a pin is rare and difficult to acquire, it gains value, becoming a coveted symbol of commitment and effort. For instance, a pin awarded to community members who complete a zero-waste challenge or bike to work for 30 days straight becomes a badge of honor, sparking conversations and inspiring others.

How to Use Pins Effectively

Here are three impactful ways sustainability managers can incorporate pins into their programs:

1. As Awards for High Performance: Recognize individuals or groups who achieve significant milestones, such as reducing energy use by 20% or volunteering for community clean-ups.
2. To Foster Group Identity: Distribute pins to members of a green team or participants in a sustainability pledge program, creating a sense of belonging and shared purpose.
3. To Secure Commitment: Use pins as rewards for signing pledges or committing to specific actions, such as switching to renewable energy or adopting a plant-based diet.

Secrets to Making Pins Work

To maximize the impact of your pins, follow these tips:

1. Design with Care: Make your pins visually appealing, with designs that are cute, beautiful, or meaningful. Avoid generic logos and opt for symbols that resonate emotionally.
2. Create Scarcity: Ensure pins are hard to earn, requiring meaningful effort or the completion of challenging tasks.
3. Award Them Publicly: Have a respected figure, such as a mayor or organization leader, present the pins during ceremonies or events to add prestige.
4. Celebrate Mastery: Reserve pins for achievements that require skill or dedication, such as mastering composting techniques or leading community sustainability projects.
5. Amplify Visibility: Highlight pin recipients in newsletters, social media, or community boards to increase recognition and inspire others.
6. Choose High-Quality Production: Invest in durable, attractive materials to ensure the pins feel valuable and lasting.

What to Avoid

Not all pins are created equal. To maintain their impact:

• Don’t Overbrand: Avoid plastering your organization’s logo prominently on the pin. The focus should be on the achievement, not the sponsor.
• Don’t Give Them Away Freely: Pins should be earned, not handed out casually.
• Don’t Skimp on Effort Requirements: Ensure pins are awarded only for meaningful actions that reflect real investment.

Evidence of Effectiveness

The power of pins is backed by research. In a study published in the Journal of Environmental Psychology (1974), individuals who wore a lapel pin promoting the Canadian Cancer Society were nearly twice as likely to donate compared to those who didn’t. This "foot-in-the-door" technique demonstrates how small tokens of recognition can lead to significant behavior shifts.

The website Psychological Science gave authors a badge when they made their publications available for open data. The badges caused a jump from 3% to 23% in the number of authors specifying open data, and to 39% the next year.

Individuals were asked donate to the Heart Association. Those who were thanked and told “You are a generous person. I wish more of the people I met were as charitable as you” gave 75% more when asked to donate to another charity.

A purely symbolic award given to Wikipedia editors increased the share of editors being active by 20 percent. The awards also raised the share of authors who contributed content to articles by 13%.

Driving Change with Pins

Custom pins are more than just accessories; they are tools for inspiring action, fostering community, and celebrating progress. Whether you’re launching a recycling campaign, organizing a tree-planting initiative, or encouraging energy conservation, pins can amplify your impact and help achieve your sustainability goals.

So, how will you design your next pin? The answer could unlock the motivation your program needs.

‍

References:
Fostering Voluntary Contributions to a Public Good: A Large-Scale Natural Field Experiment at Wikipedia, Jana Gallus, http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2579118

Kraut, R. E. (1973) Effects of social labeling on giving to charity. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 9, 551-562.

Badges to Acknowledge Open Practices: A Simple, Low-Cost, Effective Method for Increasing Transparency, http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1002456

‍