What We Can Learn From the Success of Star Ratings

Here’s a surprising, underreported fact in the climate debate: in countries like Australia and the United States, total carbon emissions have been declining over the last decade—despite population growth. Yes, really.

While headlines often focus on melting ice caps and stranded polar bears, the truth is that many developed nations have made measurable progress in decarbonizing their economies. This progress might not make for sensational news, but it’s real and worth celebrating. That said, we’re far from solving the climate crisis. Global CO₂ levels continue to rise, reaching record highs, and much more needs to be done. But the data suggests that peak carbon emissions for several developed countries may already be behind us.

Why Emissions Are Declining

The reasons for this decline are multi-faceted:

1. Economic Shifts: Slower economic growth means people are buying fewer goods, traveling less, and wasting less energy overall.
2. The Shift to Natural Gas: Natural gas emits less CO₂ per unit of energy than coal, contributing to lower emissions.
3. Rooftop Solar: The growth of rooftop solar installations has played a significant role in reducing reliance on fossil fuels.
4. Energy-Efficient Appliances: Perhaps the most impactful factor has been the dramatic improvements in energy efficiency across household and commercial appliances.

Today’s refrigerators, for example, use a fraction of the energy they consumed in the 1980s. In fact, your current fridge might use just 10% of the energy compared to the one your family had back then. Since buildings account for approximately 40% of a country’s energy use, these efficiency gains have a cumulative impact that’s hard to overstate.

The Role of Energy Star Ratings

One of the great success stories behind this evolution in efficiency is Australia’s Energy Star Rating program. It’s a masterclass in how simple disclosure can drive meaningful change.

Here’s what we can learn from its success:

1. The Power of Disclosure: Making energy data easy to find at the point of purchase empowers consumers to make informed choices.
2. Market-Driven Innovation: The government doesn’t dictate how manufacturers should improve their products. By simply mandating energy ratings, manufacturers are left free to innovate and compete.
3. Clear and Simple Design: The energy rating stickers are straightforward and easy for consumers to understand, removing barriers to action.
4. Point-of-Purchase Impact: Placing the stickers on appliances where purchasing decisions are made ensures maximum visibility and influence.
5. Industry Buy-In: Initially, appliance manufacturers resisted the legislation. But today, they embrace energy ratings as a key feature in their sales pitches.
6. Ease of Policy Adoption: Lobbying for mandatory disclosure is often more achievable than pushing for stringent industry targets. And as the Energy Star program shows, this approach can lead to even better results.

Expanding the Model

The success of Australia’s energy rating system has led to its expansion into other areas. Today, it includes water efficiency ratings for taps, showerheads, and toilets, as well as ratings for gas appliances like water heaters and stoves. This evolution underscores the program’s adaptability and effectiveness.

Why This Matters

The Energy Star Rating program demonstrates how simple, well-designed policies can drive significant environmental outcomes. By leveraging disclosure, fostering innovation, and empowering consumers, it provides a scalable model for tackling climate challenges. As we push for deeper decarbonization, we’d do well to remember the lessons of star ratings: simplicity works, and informed consumers can drive market transformation.

The future of sustainability isn’t just about ambitious targets; it’s about creating systems that make better choices easier for everyone. Star ratings show us how to light the way.

‍